Bureaucrats, confirmed, Administrators
4,558
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Created page with "We're in this weird time in history when most commercial software is touted as "proprietary" software, yet every commercial enterprise '''relies''' on GPL software. It's kind..."
We're in this weird time in history when most commercial software is touted as "proprietary" software, yet every commercial enterprise '''relies''' on GPL software. It's kinda like saying you really love the fresh air on a Spring morning while ignoring the physical reality that you share that air with every polluter on the planet. Compliance is like trying to prove on paper that the air molecules that you breathe are not and have never touched pollution. Selling proprietary software is like trying to sell packaged air because "it's clean". It would be a better world if we just focused our energy on eliminating air pollution. Until we have such Utopia, we have companies trying to document their compliance at the least possible cost.
== Compliance between Licenses ==
The compliance drama is not just one between proprietary and free software. There is an over abundance of software licenses, and many of the so-called 'open source' or 'permissive' licenses are incompatible with each other. So, compliance is actually about what code you have, what license is that code under, and are you compliant with all the terms of every license that you are a party to.
== Enforcement ==
There isn't some big government agency like the FBI (who prosecutes you if you copy a movie) working to ensure that free code remains free. Instead, the effort is literally left to the little guy. The [https://sfconservancy.org/ Software Freedom Conservancy] is the main actor in enforcement. They are a charity drawing their financial support from individuals. https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/principles.html Meanwhile, the big guys certainly do have lots of money to enforce violations of their licenses (http://www.bsa.org/).
== Resources ==
Bradley Kuhn (and the FSF?) put together https://copyleft.org where you can find
; https://copyleft.guide : Copyleft and the GNU General Public License: A Comprehensive Tutorial and Guide
; https://gpl.guide : Part I Detailed Analysis of the GNU GPL and Related Licenses
; https://compliance.guide : Part II A Practical Guide to GPL Compliance
== Vendors ==
BlackDuck here in Massachusetts sells compliance as do other firms like [http://triplecheck.net/ TripleCheck]
== Other ==
http://www.linuxfoundation.org/programs/legal/compliance
== Compliance between Licenses ==
The compliance drama is not just one between proprietary and free software. There is an over abundance of software licenses, and many of the so-called 'open source' or 'permissive' licenses are incompatible with each other. So, compliance is actually about what code you have, what license is that code under, and are you compliant with all the terms of every license that you are a party to.
== Enforcement ==
There isn't some big government agency like the FBI (who prosecutes you if you copy a movie) working to ensure that free code remains free. Instead, the effort is literally left to the little guy. The [https://sfconservancy.org/ Software Freedom Conservancy] is the main actor in enforcement. They are a charity drawing their financial support from individuals. https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/principles.html Meanwhile, the big guys certainly do have lots of money to enforce violations of their licenses (http://www.bsa.org/).
== Resources ==
Bradley Kuhn (and the FSF?) put together https://copyleft.org where you can find
; https://copyleft.guide : Copyleft and the GNU General Public License: A Comprehensive Tutorial and Guide
; https://gpl.guide : Part I Detailed Analysis of the GNU GPL and Related Licenses
; https://compliance.guide : Part II A Practical Guide to GPL Compliance
== Vendors ==
BlackDuck here in Massachusetts sells compliance as do other firms like [http://triplecheck.net/ TripleCheck]
== Other ==
http://www.linuxfoundation.org/programs/legal/compliance
